In my mind,
romance novels are somewhere between a woman’s best enemy and her worst friend.
They are empowering and totally destructive. I guess it also depends on what
kind of romance novel they are too… Mainly my experience with them have been
the historical fiction ones (Harlequin Historical, maybe?). I’m definitely no
expert on romance novels or feminism or how the romance genre affects women. I
just know my experience and what I believe.
Romance
novels give a reflection of truth while spinning total lies at the same time.
Let’s look at Twilight. It is not only
fantasy that vampires and werewolves exist, but the romance is a boat load of
fantasy. Sorry, there’s no high school girl who is ready for that level of attraction.
He fricken stalks her and watches her sleep without her knowing it! No, there
is no romance in that. They are both obsessed, which does happen in high
school. But there is a thick line between obsession and love. There is no “one
and only”. There is no “forever and ever”. There is the one you love and there
is the lifetime you have to spend with them (Oh, I believe in heaven, but I’m
going to be a bit too amazed at the glory of God to care too much about who I
married. I’m just going to want to worship forever!).
Then there
is the even more common mistake in romance novels between lust and love. Don’t
get me wrong, I love that the two love each other’s bodies. That’s good and
important. But when they’re jumping into bed before they know how they and/or
the other person feels, that’s not healthy. And more often than not, right
after the sex of night together, there’s a fight. Doubts boil over and the
characters are starting to have regrets. Hmm, think those were preventable by
an honest conversation? There’s always still some secret. Yes, let’s look at
get naked and be intimate, but only physically. Emotionally, I’m going to stay
fully dressed and aloof. That’s love, right?
You want to
know what’s totally seductive to me? Les
Miserables. The Elderly are Made to go out When Convenient. Jean Valjean
still has his arm in a sling (the end of the chapter). There is so much love
and romance happening there. The first one is when Marius and Cosset finally get
to talk because they have been admiring each other from a distance, in love since
they first really saw each other. The first thing that comes out of Marius’s mouth?
Ramblings. Then they sit in the garden and just talk about everything until “These
two hearts poured themselves put to each other, so that at the end of an hour,
it was the young man who had the girl’s soul and the girl who had the soul of
the young man… When they had finished, when they had told each other
everything, she laid her head on his shoulder, and asked him: ‘What is your
name?’” I love that. What’s a name when you know everything about him because
he told you it all and you shared yourself right back. They don’t know the
first thing about romance, but why would they need to?
The second
chapter I mentioned, the last part is their wedding night. I don’t care how
good of a love scene is in a bodice ripper novel, just give me some good old
fashioned Hugo. I’d rather have angels, light, and joy than undressing and
touching. I don’t need to know what happened behind closed doors, I just want
to know that it was love and it was pure.
No comments:
Post a Comment